A Short Rant (the best kind!)

An article in today’s New York Times book review got me thinking. Alright, it got me hopping mad. Dave Itzkoff was reviewing China Mieville’s Un Lun Dun as well as Neil Gaiman and Michael Reaves’ collaboration Interworld, and both reviews were mostly good.

Basically, Itzkoff’s praise focused on the daring, genre-defying boldness of the books. Itzkoff’ applauds the subversion of expectations and can’t help but aim swipe at what he sees as the Potter franchise’s predictable formula. He even goes so far as to ask, “I sometimes wonder what self-respecting author of speculative fiction can find fulfillment in writing novels for young readers.”

Them’s fighting words! To say that speculative fiction writers are somehow above YA writing, is like the band geek throwing spit wads at the mathlete. Just sad.

The truth is that writers of YA are working in all genres – literary, sci-fi, fantasy, crime, romance – and the only difference is that we are trying to create a product that will excite the youth of today. We are building readers by building good, fun stories. We want them to like our books, sure, because we want them to LOVE reading (something that Itzkoff leaves out of his critique – whether the kids will actually like the stories).

Don’t get me wrong – I’m not commenting on either of the books being reviewed. Both are on my bookshelf. And I’m thrilled that the Times is giving ink to genre titles these days, but Mr. Itzkoff’s offhand slam against the entire YA genre made me nearly spit coffee.

Young Adult writing is a net good. End of debate.


4 Responses to “A Short Rant (the best kind!)”

  1. Hi Matt – You’re right! The first rule of ANY kind of writing is to know your audience. If you’re writing primarily to an audience of men, you’ll write differently than to an audience of women. If you’re writing to an audience of well read college graduates, it will be different than writing to teenagers. But, the difference is in your ability to get the story or the message across in the language that speaks to them. It’s got nothing to do with formula.

  2. Thanks for the link, Dave. I have yet to see anyone actually defend Itzkoff’s comments . . .

  3. […] say so in public (or on the blogosphere, which is pretty much the same thing). kt literary client Matthew Cody responds: Them’s fighting words! To say that speculative fiction writers are somehow above YA writing, […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: